Showing posts with label cartooning. Show all posts
Showing posts with label cartooning. Show all posts

Monday, February 15, 2016

Day 46: Christopher Hart's "Cartoon Cool"

Quick Overview
 
Level: Beginner / Intermediate
Tone: Step-by-step
Pages: 112
Published: 2005
Arbitrary Rating: 4/5
Plan to Reread: Yes




My Opinion:

Over the years I have seen more books by Christopher Hart than I can count.  The guy has something published for pretty much every style you can find.  I'm not entirely clear on the why, but he's also pretty polarizing in the drawing community.  Some people like his books a lot, some people hate them.  There's even a few people who have dedicated web sites to why you shouldn't read Hart's stuff.

My local library had a copy of "Cartoon Cool: How to Draw New Retro-Style Characters" and I couldn't really pass on a whole collection of guides just because of some mix reviews.  Plus, this style is still way outside the range that I typically draw so the bar for improvement is pretty low.

One tip that I learned directly from this read is that you add bold lines by tracing along only one side of the original sketch.  This probably sounds super obvious to anyone who has experience drawing, but I had always assumed you just trace over the original line.  That's why my lines would wobble back and forth on both sides of the original and always looked awful.

Learning something new, even something small is a step in the right direction for me.  I also appreciate that the pages are stuffed with examples and step by step guides instead of pages of discussion on what makes a cartoon style.  I'm not sure I'm ready to give Hart a glowing review for all of his publications, but this one is definitely worth a read if you're looking to draw cartoons.

Monday, February 1, 2016

Day 32: John M. Byrne's "Cartooning: The Best One-Stop Guide to Drawing Cartoons, Caricatures, Comic Strips, and Manga"

Quick Overview
 
Level: Beginner
Tone: Introduction Guide
Pages: 191
Published: 2008
Arbitrary Rating: 4/5
Plan to Reread: No



My Opinion:

Phew, that's a mouthful right?  John M. Byrne's "Cartooning" is a crash course in a variety of artistic disciplines that you can find in that crazy title.  As an example, chapter 7 is on caricatures and is about twenty pages long with multiple illustrations on most pages.

I really like this approach for beginners because it's easy to follow along with the visuals and there's just enough instruction to get your feet wet.  That being said, if you're looking to improve on any of these styles you're going to need way more than the one or two examples provided in this book.

The chapter on humor, using puns, and generating interesting ideas was probably my favorite.  A lot of books take the approach of showing you a pretty picture and then breaking it up into a few easy to follow steps.  Byrne gives advice on tools to use, writing tips, and observation techniques to choose the best details when translating from real life to cartoon.

While the contents of this book may not carry you as far as a more academic text, it has plenty to offer in an enjoyable and colorful presentation.  That's one of my biggest gripes so far.  Most of the books I've been reading through are so heavily focused on the use of charcoals and pencils that they don't bother to include any colored illustrations.  Looking at 100+ pages of black and white can be a real drag, so I'm happy to find a guide that goes that extra step.